I finally saw the show last week. I'd been entering the lottery and losing everyday, then I checked the ticketing site and found out that there was one single ticket left for the entirety of the run. I took it as a sign and bought it. It was more than I ever spent on a show, but it was so worth it.
The best part of the production was definitely its immersive nature. "The Dead" is one of my favorite stories of all time, and it was wonderful to see it come to life. My favorite moments were the quiet, lingering glances, the exasperated sighs, the muttered comments, etc. that made the text feel so real and alive. I really felt as though I was attending a dinner party and eavesdropping on all the conversations around me.
All the performances were rich and nuanced. I was especially impressed by the musical talent - the actor portraying Bartell D'Arcy sang "The Lass of Aughrim" beautifully and made the last scene so poignant and haunting. The food was excellent as well. I sat directly behind Boyd Gaines and Kate Burton, and had an excellent view at their interactions. Boyd stayed in character throughout the meal (nervously practicing his speech under his breath), but at one point, Kate turned and asked us how the food was, and said she can't enjoy it because she has to eat it seven times a week, haha.
My one issue was with how clunky the adaptation was. I agree with the reviews that said the exposition was delivered in a really heavy-handed way. At times, it felt like the performers were just pointing at something and going "Ah yes, this conveniently placed object reminds me of this piece of my character's backstory..." The copy-and-paste approach wasn't a huge problem for the most part, but it was nearly fatal in the last scene for me.
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
Kate was heartbreaking in her restraint, but I was completely taken out of the scene when Boyd started reciting the last couple of paragraphs from the story, nearly word for word. He delivered it beautifully and with such commitment, and I fully understand the impulse to preserve Joyce's prose, but it felt so dense and unnatural in this context. The film version didn't handle it perfectly either, but at least the voiceover cut it down to a manageable length.
Perhaps the last scene is just impossible to adapt, considering that it consists almost entirely of internal reflection, but this approach took me out of the scene entirely, and stood in such stark contrast to the rest of the show, which had felt so real and naturalistic.
Still, I think the immersive staging does wonders for the show, and this has become one of my favorite theatrical experiences ever. I really felt like a guest invited to these characters' homes, and I'm grateful that they allowed me to take a look at their interior lives. It was a special night, and I hope they bring it back again.