I think she's great, most of the time. And of course, she's beautiful and talented. But a 39- year- old Elle Woods? Terrible idea. Unless they conceived the show as someone said earlier in this thread, as a Grease- like, older- playing- younger parody...
This just would not work. She might come off cute-sy and fun onstage, but this doesn't directly mean that she comes off young.
[title of show] on Broadway. it's time. believe.