I saw it in March and was head-over-heels about it. I was not a fan of Kerry Butler's Audrey (although I am a fan of Kerry), but Tari Kelly knocked my socks off. Also, she's a very sweet person. I checked out her website after the show and sent her an email saying how much I enjoyed her performance and had hoped to come say hi after the show (but alas, I was with 5 other college students who were like, "No, I'm hungry, let's go to Taco Bell *whinewhinewhine*"), and she emailed me back, asked for my address, and sent me a Playbill autographed by the entire cast!! I obviously haven't seen the understudy, but I have heard good things. Terrific show (better than it was in NYC in my opinion, though I heart Hunter Foster).
Ashley