I was at the Shaw July 22-28 and saw all 10 productions. I always say the Shaw is like sleepaway camp for theatre fans.
Mack and Mabel musically was pretty good. The book does sink it and I don't think the show will ever really work. It belongs on the list of unfixable heartbreakers like Merrily We Roll Along. Benedict Campbell is so strong and so damn good as Mack Sennet that he over shadows Glynnis Ranney, and I felt the show ought to be called "Mack and Mack and Mabel".
As for Time Heals Everything, why have her wander all over the stage? What is wrong with planting her DSL or DSR, have her sing, then move during the musical interlude and then have her stand still again while she finishes the song?
My A+ list for this season is:
Summer and Smoke which took a B list Williams play and made it A list. This is the reason to travel to NotL this season. The company is justifyably very proud of this production.
The Cassilis Engagement is a terrifically funny, witty and pungent comedy about the class system and warfare in early 1900s Britain. This is also a must-see. It could use a NY production.
Both A Month in the Country and Saint Joan are also on the must list.
Tristan, an original musical, is a nice try, but is not assembled well. There are some good songs and the cast is admirable, but the book needs major restructuring. This is the only show that I found lacking although the production is strong. The audience ate it up so you could say 'what the hell do I know?'
This was my 6th trip to the Shaw Fest in 7 years. The Shaw is remarkably easy to get to and is actually closer to the Buffalo airport than Toronto. The bulk of the season runs through October 7. Once you get there, you really do not need a car. There is not much nightlife so you eat, sleep, shop, take walks, swim at the municipal pool and go to the theatre. What else is there?
This year's big drawback for those of us from the US? Our dollar is weak and it is about par with the Canadian dollar. In 2001-02 it was about 1USD=1.50CD.
Go and you'll get hooked. You will probably also be the youngest people in the theatre at least on a weekday.
"If my life weren't funny, it would just be true. And that would be unacceptable."
--Carrie Fisher