"ampie, thanks for the feedback. Sounds like you were really close getting rush .
We're only in for a short trip, so if i did rush, it would be a Fri or Sat night...but it is 2 weeks before it closes so that may up the numbers. I just need to figure out which one has better luck as we don't have a ton of time in NY and don't want to hold back my family from doing other things while I'm in line."
I did Mamma Mia's rush this morning. I got to the box office at 8am and was first on line but by 8:30 there were about 14 people behind me. I was shocked! By the time they opened, the line was almost at the Majestic!
Granted, there were 2 shows today so it might not be a good indication of what a Friday or Saturday would look like.
What I did learn / notice:
A Shubert employee who works at the theater told me that yesterday they only gave about 4 rush tickets.
Most of the partial view seats around me weren't occupied by people I saw in the rush line, but, by people who paid $70 in advance. I'm not sure how many tickets they ended up giving but I noticed the front box on the other side of the theater was occupied by 2 people from the rush line as well, and the 8 box seats behind them were not people from the line in the morning. I was given Orchestra row C seats 14 and 16.
Hope this information helps!