I did the whole listing-every-artist thing for a while, but my artists section got to be a hot damn mess and I didn't like that, so I now use the composer for the show as the artist for each album. Which of course means that jukebox musicals get confused; if there's one artist the show is using its source, like All Shook Up or Jersey Boys, since the songs are composed by a large number of people, I use the artist in question: Elvis Presley and The Four Seasons. For Mamma Mia! I use Benny Andersson & Bjorn Ulvaeus, and the stage version of Once I actually use The Swell Season (as I have other albums by Markéta Irglová and Glen Hansard under that duo name). For non-artist specific jukebox musicals (like Baby, It's You, Rock of Ages and Priscilla Queen of the Desert) I have taken to listing the album's producer as the artist.
JoseLee, I may use that Vocal genre you talked about. Most of my albums by Broadway singers I have listed under "Broadway" if the album includes songs from musicals.
I also have some Tony-related playlists, including 4 that are Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Featured Actress and Best Featured Actor in a musical. For these I use my favorite track the Tony winner is featured on the recording of their winning role. Which makes me sad when the winner isn't recorded (like Judy Kaye in Phantom and the boys from Billy Elliot are ones that spring to mind). A couple times the winning role doesn't have a featured track on the whole album (like Peg Murray for Cabaret in 1966, she doesn't sing anywhere on that album although her character sings, at least in the 1998 version).
"Contentment, it seems, simply happens. It appears accompanied by no bravos and no tears."
Updated On: 5/8/15 at 12:13 PM