Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 - New Recording

I've really been getting into the original recording lately from 2013, especially with the help of genius.com (the lyrics to which composer/lyricist Dave Malloy added annotations about 2 weeks ago). When I first heard the recording I thought it was very strange and didn't attempt to listen to it again until last October and within the last few weeks I've been listening repeatedly. The cast for the upcoming Broadway production is mostly the same, with only Josh Groban, Denée Benton and a few others replacing the original off-Broadway cast. Especially with internationally beloved recording star Josh Groban, does anyone think they may go the Fun Home route and just have the new stars record their songs, slap a new cover on it and call it good? It seems like it would especially behoove the production to release an album with Groban.

Updated On: 5/21/16 at 04:11 PM

I suspect a whole new recording as well....Between Groban and Denee that covers an awful lot that would need to be recorded.

There is also some new material, including a big solo for Pierre, so I imagine that most, if not all of the show will be recorded. Almost every track features Natasha or Pierre, so it would probably be easier to just record a brand new CD.

Yeah, I mean, I can only imagine it being a whole new recording since, as you say, Groban's voice is totally different from Malloy's, so it really will be a whole new kind of Pierre. And if they do make a new recording, it will be a really interesting comparison between the original off-Broadway versions of his songs and the Broadway versions...The duel in particular seems to me a difficult thing to imagine Groban singing (without blowing out his vocal cords), as well as the scene towards the end where he confronts Anatole.

A new cast recording is definitely being made, and soon. It just won't be recorded on December 5th.