Just a bump, lots of good suggestions here but we've ran into a couple issues the last couple days on getting people to do it that are dedicated for this competition. Our original plan months ago was to do The Opening from SFANW but the two guys who are putting this group together (myself included) are actually a bass and a baritone and singing up for us just didn't sound too good so we ditched that idea. Grease, too overplayed. Listened to the songs from A New Brain and weren't overly impressed, they were okay, possibilities. Bye Bye Birdie is too cheesy for us, lol. The others I haven't looked into yet but will soon.
We have for sure three guys (a bass and two high baritones/low tenors) and a girl (a soprano in chorus but could pretty much do anything other than opera) that would be in a group if needed. We'd need to work to find more. I'm just brainstorming, I know I'm a pain in the ass

but thanks for all the help guys.