Newsies

I have heard lots of people say Newsies would be great on Broadway, but it is only being released for community theatre and high school type productions by MTI. My question is everybody says they think it'd be great, but how exactly do you see it working? I think the story would need fleshed out adding larger parts for certain characters and plot lines. There was even a petition online for a while trying to get it on Broadway. Does everyone here like Newsies or do we have anyone who doesn't like it? Why or why wouldn't Newsies be successful on broadway? Would Disney even consider doing it? (I have heard they are against it. Note:I don't remember where I heard that.) I would love to hear what everyone thinks, and actually dicuss the possibility. Please lets not have this become one of those "I would cast (insert favorite actor who wouldn't even be right for the part here)in that part!" threads. I want to discuss how likely it is that this would ever happen, and how it could be done. I would appreciate it if anyone is better informed on this than I and are at liberty to share what they know could "enlighten" us. While I personally doubt it ever will, I would love for it to happen so I am exploring the remote possibilities.

---

Updated On: 2/22/04 at 03:53 AM

As a child, I also enjoyed Newsies very much, but watching the movie now makes my teeth ache a little. The Alan Menken songs are good, but the story seems forced and cliched, especially since so much of it was fabricated (for example, there was no great victory for the Newsies- they reached a compromise that really didn't gain them much). If the creators went back to the source material and, using the existing songs and some new ones, recreated the show as a darker, deeper piece, I think it could be an excellent stage show.

Is the script available at the Drama Book Shop? I'd love to see how they adapted it for the stage, especially if it's only intended for schools.

---

Hello everyone. This is my first post. I've been reading for awhile and thought I would jump in finally since I love Newsies so much:)
I think it could be done. They wouldn't have to use children for the entire cast. They could use twentysomethings for the older boys and late teens that look young for the younger boys and then children for the rest.
I think Newsies would do great on Broadway, the songs from the movie are great and it's a cool story.

ah, my favortie movie musical =)

Actually ,I don't feel the movie would need to be changed too much to work on Broadway. I'd like a few more songs added, but the music is already really fun. As far as cating kids, you don't really need a lot of boys under the age of 15 with the exception of Les. Christian Bale and most of the other guys were already close to 18/19 when he movie was made. Max Casella was 25!!! As far as thebook/script bring cliche, well, I can see why people thin kthat, but I still just think it's a cute, sweet, inspiring story and i'd hate to see it made more "dark" or "realistic". So, those are my two cents. Here's to hoping it opens on Broadway soon!! =D

I love the movie. When I watch it, I feel like it was intended for stage. They have common meeting areas that would be the same sets used again and again throughout the show. It could be darker but I dont think it needs to be. Christian Bale's character was supposed to be 17 I believe, he says it in the movie. All the people in Hairspray are supposed to be 16 and they're like 24-30. It could be done. Ive shown the movie to lots of people and never had someone say they didnt like it.

-Christina

I love Newsies too (duh) and saw a production many years ago put on by a performing arts high school. Disney had given them special permission to produce it. I thought it worked very well, and I definitely saw possibilities of bigger productions. But, you're right about the problem of the young cast. I remember that they changed even some of the tame lyrics (like in Ann Margret song - instead of "I stick out my chest", they sang "I look my best")

Jon,
Did you know that Polly featured Menken music also? Or was that just a coincidence?

Well sure, Les is "near ten" but my point atleast was that most of the bigger roles amongst the newsies are kids 16/17 and on broadway those kinds of roles are easily played by 20something yr olds.

-Christina

A little OT but oh well.

My drama teacher got very excited when she heard about this and she put our school's name down to be a "test school" for the show. What would this entail? Anyone know?

I think Newsies would make a great Bwy production, as long as the book is tightened and a couple of clincher songs are added. It could appeal to families wanting to see a show but who have outgrown Beauty & the Beast and The Lion King. Big River was a hit, and I speculate appealed to that demographic -- families with 10-14-yr-old kids.

But I think the clincher for whether it would be a smash success is if a breakout star could be discovered to carry the show. To get teen girls to want to see such a show, I think there needs to be a magnetic teenage boy who carries the show. I think that because it's history-based and gritty (like Oliver and Les Mis), young teen boys will be interested in the subject, but I don't think the subject alone will appeal to girls unless there is a male lead who is a "must see" attraction.

As for the problems of a young cast, I imagine they are many. But the half-dozen boys in the current Gypsy seem to be fantastically talented and professional.

i love that movie, i think it would be and ok musical on bway. i think if they slap the word "disney" infront of it, it might work. some people are saps for disney.

I think you underestimate teenage girls. "A show with all boys! Oh my gosh, we are SO there!" Most of the Newsies fanatics I've ever met were teenage girls.

I think this would be a great stage show!

---

Elvis is completely right.

---