I saw the show today. I'm not a huge dance person and I've only ever seen one show at the Old Globe that was any better than "horrible", but I loved Gatelli's work in Newsies, so I drove down to San Diego to check it out. Overall, I enjoyed it, but wasn't blown away. Some of the vignettes worked, some didn't. For me, the segments from Nottage, Fisher and Hwang were the standouts. I was particularly bored by the segments from Beane and McNally. Because of the way the vignettes flowed, everybody in the cast got a moment to be featured, but there wasn't a lot of chance for dancers to pop. The only dancers that mesmerized me were Jess LeProtto, Erica Wong, and Alex Michael Stoll. I was unfamiliar with the latter two and am eager to see them again.
Also, when I sat down, I was actually really glad that there wasn't going to be an intermission -- but after about 90 minutes, I was desperate for one. Glad I went, and would recommend, but don't see this having much of a life beyond this staging -- at least not without some work.