YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN: If you show up at the box office three hours prior to curtain, you will most definitely be able to snatch up a pair of front center orchestra seats for $121.50 a piece.
JERSEY BOYS: Definitely buy them now. I'm not familiar with the exact sightlines far back in the August Wilson Orchestra, so maybe someone else can be more helpful location-wise, but I do know that once you reach a certain row in the Orchestra the set begins to be obstructed by the mezzanine overhang, so keep that in mind.
THE LITTLE MERMAID: It's hard to say at this point since we're still in previews. Hold out until next month to see what reviews look like and any impact they might have on sales.
WICKED: Since you only need one ticket, if you really want a great seat, you could definitely just wait and get a great single seat on the cancellation line on the day of the performance, and avoid all of those nasty Ticketmaster service charges for a seat that definitely won't be as good.
A CATERED AFFAIR, CRY-BABY, HAIRSPRAY, AVENUE Q, XANADU, RENT, A CHORUS LINE, LEGALLY BLONDE: Wait for BroadwayBox discount codes. You most definitely will be able to get discount seats from TKTS for HAIRSPRAY, AVENUE Q, XANADU, RENT, A CHORUS LINE, LEGALLY BLONDE, and most likely A CATERED AFFAIR.
But here is the main question you should be asking yourself:
How much time do you want to be spending on your trip trying to get tickets? All of this takes some work. It may be worth it for you to buy most of your tickets online in advance with BroadwayBox discount codes (for those that will have them) and pay the service charges, so all you will need to do on the day of the performance is show up at the theatre 30 minutes prior to curtain, and the rest of your time can be spent enjoying the city.
The whole ticket searching game can be frustrating and stressful, and at times disappointing. I would say, though, that if you know how to play the game, 95% of the time it works out in your favor, and you end up with great seats to the show you want to attend for a discounted price, but it's up to you regarding how much time you want to devote to the process.
If you have any other questions, don't hesitate to ask. Feel free to PM me as well.
Best of luck planning your trip!
"Winning a Tony this year is like winning Best Attendance in third grade: no one will care but the winner and their mom."
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)