For those who have not seen "1776", yet...let me recommend, if you go, to sit in the Orchestra section, preferably middle rows of any Orchestra section (right, left , middle, are all great). And, of course, the front rows would be amazing!
I had tickets for front Mezz, and it was like seeing a miniature version of the stage down there...it really felt like you needed a telescope to see the show! =I The "boxes" were a bit closer, but I still recommend the Orchestra section...since I meant to go another time, I figured I would get the Mezz, and then go for the Orchestra the next time.
About the NJ transit, just take it from Penn Station to Millburn, and then walk to Paper Mill. The path is not available at the moment, so you will have to go around to get there, but it is clearly marked, no confusion.
And...yes, if you go for the night show, the Millburn train does not go straight to Manhattan after 10:30PM (show ends about 10:45PM). You have to take the connection (at Millburn) which goes to, I believe, Hoboken? Someone correct me if I got this last one wrong, but this is what they told me at Paper Mill. Then from Hoboken to Penn Station. It leaves Millburn about 11:35PM (and I think this is the last train, at least weekdays). You might want to check with NJ transit before you embark on this trip, if you are going for the night performance, just in case the train might not be operating that night.
Updated On: 5/3/09 at 03:00 AM