I used to love Idina Menzel but now I can't stand her.
I was a big Patti Lupone fan for a while but I've kind of gotten over her and, as someone else said, her book bothered me a bit.
I still love Sutton Foster but her voice doesn't transfer well to recording, I find. I have the 2011 Anything Goes soundtrack but I can't really listen to it too much because her voice starts to irritate me. (She's an amazing dancer though!)
"Nice is different than good."