Broadway Buddy said: "Has anyone tried getting Moulin Rouge, Betrayal, or Beautiful from the box offices? Going to the city on Sunday hoping to collect these 3.
BTW ones that have said no to me in the past are Hadestown, Beetlejuice, Ain't Too Proud, Aladdin, and Dear Evan Hansen.
Ones that have said yes include Tootsie, Hamilton, Book of Mormon, Waitress, Mockingbird, Oklahoma!, Constitution, Phantom, and The Lion King.
Don't know if that was helpful to anyone, but just in case anyone was curious."
I got one from Moulin Rouge. The first time I asked, the box office rep looked below the counter and said he was out, which I took as a cue that they normally hold them. So next time I was in the area, I asked again and the box office rep (different person) was happy to give me two.
As for Hadestown and Beetlejuice, I guess it depends who is at the box office that day. I've been told that they don't hold any at Hadestown, but my friend was able to get one the next day. This was before the Tony's though, and I never tried again. Likewise for Beetlejuice, I was told by one box office rep that they weren't allowed to give them out. Sometime after, a different friend had told me she was able to get one, so I came back the next time I was in the area and a different rep was more than happy to give me one.
Adding to this list, the shows that told me that they didn't offer playbills at the box office (that are still open) were Oklahmona!, Mean Girls, Hamilton, and Come From Away. Though the first two told me to come back 30 minutes to curtain and ask security (which I didn't do).