I actually post-dated tickets for She Loves Me not long ago and had a great experience!
I got sick in February and had to miss the show. I called Roundabout on a Saturday morning a couple of weeks afterward and was told there were no spots available that day for general admission. So I tried another Saturday and was told yes. We got to the theater as usual and went to the box office. We were given numbered slips and were told to wait in the back of the orchestra. There were five of us that night who were doing general admission.
We had to wait until everyone was seated, and then the usher beckoned for us. We ended up with great seats in the center orchestra! My own seats had been in the mezzanine. I think the ushers just try to get you in the easiest spot available, because there's not a lot of time. Be sure to tell the usher that you want to sit together.
The only strange part is that an usher came to get us at intermission and told us to wait in the back of the theater again. I guess that's in case the rightful owner of the seats showed up. Then, at the end of the intermission, we were told to go back to where we had been sitting.
Because you can go during the week, I bet you'll have no trouble getting in.
It's a great show and I was very pleased that Roundabout allowed us to post-date our tickets.
Updated On: 5/3/16 at 06:48 PM