One of you said that you loved Phantom on DVD. I did enjoy it, but saw it shortly after I had just seen the nat'l tour multiple times. It is VERY difficult to see the show on the stage, and then go into the theater to see it on the big screen. I actually was disappointed with it at the time, but as its settled in, i enjoy it much more than i did.
As for rent, the first time I saw it, it was way too long for me. I didn't know the story, nor many of the songs. If you don't know any of those things - omg, trust me it drags. However, I am familiar with the story, songs, and performers now, so appreciate it and like it MUCH more than I did
The stage to movie shows need to grow on me before I really like them. I ADORE the stage performances, and am always "so-so" with the movies at first. Same thing happened w/ Hairspray. I had JUST seen it on the nat'l tour, and months later it was on DVD.
I would love to see Ave Q on DVD

! Hehe - just my opinion.