x-posting from the other thread:
It was light fare and I think a great first attempt at what could become a great variety show in the future.
I agree that the palette needs to be brightened up like Judy Garland's show and it has to feel overall less forced.
I feel like giving prizes to the audience cheapened the experience.
Cirque du Soleil should book Alanis ASAP because she is clearly already fluent in Cirque-ish (gibberish)
I think on paper all of it worked, but just needed some tweaking.
I feel like Rosie doesn't need to be cut out of musical numbers, but she doesn't need to be attempting to sing along with the professional talent. I was picturing the song "Like Zis/Like Zat" being a great song for a variety show, and in that case if she were to be involved she should be the talk-sing part. I was surprised to hear that her harmonizing was actually quite nice, most notably with Gloria Estefan.
The celebrity drop-ins are fun, but they shouldn't be fully staged/scripted. Let Rosie play the 'straight man' to whatever ridiculous fodder they bring up just like Carson did and the celebs will be pounding down the door.
I think if they're able to marry the idea of what many of the late night TV shows have become (monologue, funny clips, interview of celeb) with the variety format and mold them together into a cohesive show, she'll have a hit on her hands.
Updated On: 11/27/08 at 05:19 AM