The production that played Drury Lane Oakbrook in 2010 remains one of the best pieces of theatre I have ever seen. It was directed by the great Rachel Rockwell, who sadly passed away earlier this year. No other production I have seen has equaled it. It felt epic, yet incredibly intimate. Smaller versions of the show which try to get the minimalism often miss what makes the story (both the musical and the book) so great--its epic sweep. In Ragtime, you feel that you are getting to see a large cross-section of humanity. The opening number does not work as well with 20 people as it does with 40. When we travel from the world of New Rochelle to Harlem and back, the space needs to feel like it's transforming as well, which was my main issue with the 2009 revival. It doesn't need all of the stuff that cluttered Galati's original production, but the world of the play is so vital to the story that it needs something. So I lean away from embracing a minimalist approach.
As for the cast, I'd love to see Norm Lewis reprise his role from the 2013 concert, and Adrianna Hicks (Celie on the current Color Purple tour) would be my ideal Sarah. I agree with those saying Kelli O'Hara would be a fantastic Mother. And is there anyone more perfect for Tateh than Danny Burstein?