Agree with "Falling Slowly" – I’ve heard it covered everywhere. Jazz bar bands, studio recordings, weddings, etc. Same for “And I am telling you…”
I think the problem with trying to decide if songs become standards/hits is 1. they have to have meaning outside the show, 2. they have to stick to popular music structure, i.e. some sort of clear chorus-verse distinction. Because then you can have easy excerpts of it, which means earworms are easier to come by.
So if we use that criteria, I might even put in a word for “Dear Theodosia”, which strongly reminds me of “Hey There Delilah” for some reason...
Now, if we’re talking about standards as in musical theater standards, or audition standards, then that’s something very different. We’d have the above-mentioned “Gimme Gimme”, SR!’s “Right Hand Man” (which imo isn’t easy to sing!), “Astonishing” (which Sutton Foster said was the hardest song she’d ever done), “Telephone Wire”, and more. For kids’ audition songs, “Ring of Keys”, perhaps Matilda’s “Quiet”?
Updated On: 9/30/15 at 10:00 AM