Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I've seen Rent a few times. Tonight, I witnessed something I've never seen in the Nederlander. The passion of the cast, understudies and regulars, made it the best performance on that stage I've ever seen.

Understudies tonight were Justin Brill as Mark and Moeisha McGill as Mimi. Frenchie was also out. Crystal Monee Hall did her parts and a brilliant SoL solo.

I have extremely high marks for everyone in the cast. Tim Howar was the best Roger I can remember. He's a great rock singer, though his accent, whatever kind it is, often times comes out. It makes the performance even better.

Ava Gaudet, looking like a combination of a young Idina Menzel & Julianna Margulies brought the house down as Maureen. I counted 20 "gottas" during OtM (though she admits to 11). Her valley-girl accent during the parts of that was hilarious. Wasn't she sick a few months ago?

I didn't expect to see Nicole Lewis, late of Sidd and Lennon, as Joanne. She's perfect in the part. Ask her about Sidd and you'll have a great laugh!

Moeisha McGill is a very soulful Mimi. Her Out Tonight dance on the catwalk was great (it was a surprise to learn that it was her 6th time on). Justin Brill was a great Mark. He was extremely genuine in the part, compared to Matt Caplan, who, every time I've been there, phoned it in.

Destan Owens and Justin Johnston can never be topped. 4 years and counting, they're delivering outstanding performances.

I think the show seems so fresh because of 2 elements: the extremely enthusiastic audience, who were on their feet after almost every song, and the youthfulness of the cast. They all seemed to love what they're doing, moreso now. They're bursting with excitement and it shows. I spotted Chris Hanke in the audience. He cannot wait to join the cast. It'll be a welcome edition.

Updated On: 7/19/06 at 12:06 AM

#2

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I totally agree with you. The cast is awesome. It sucks that you didn't get a chance to see Antonoque as Mimi. She is the best Mimi ever. She leaves it all on the stage and she has an amazing voice. She stole the show for me.

Justin and Destan are amazing.
#3

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I agree that Crystal is great in that role. I love every aspect of it with her.

Tim has an English accent? Since when? He's Canadian. :) Maybe he picked it up from Ruthie.

Ava had surgery and treatment for cancer of the thyroid in the winter months.

Glad you enjoyed the show.
#4

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Justin and Destan are STILL in the show? Gah...glad they're still doing well though!
"If it walks like a Parks, if it wobbles like a Parks, then it's definitely fat and nobody loves it." --MA
#5

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Ha, I totally thought Tim was British.

It's striking that you hear of so many people liking the understudies better than the regulars.

Hanke is going to be fabulous. My mom and my brother are seeing the show in about a month, each for their first time. While I'm not ready to return yet, I'm glad they'll be seeing a cast that has energy, at the very least.
A work of art is an invitation to love.
#6

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

"Destan Owens and Justin Johnston can never be topped."

They have been.

And there certainly was no sense at all of young Idina Menzel's spot-on Maureen Johnson in anything Ava Gaudet did...

#7

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

awww yay I'm glad you had a good time. Tim Howar is my favorite Roger! I love love love his portrayal. I also am glad to hear that Justin was in and doing great! I cannot stand Caplan but I can't wait for Hanke!
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
#8

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

The best performance of Rent that I have ever seen, and granted I saw the original cast back in 96' was just recently as well. I was one of the fanatics waiting in line the day after the 10th anniversary performance, and the line was huge! The day after performance was amazing. It was with Antonoque and Ava who rocked down the house. I had to look twice with Ava who looks exactly like Idina but that performance had be swept, and now I know why I have seen it on stage 7 times. Amazing!! But I must agree with all of you on Matt Caplan and thats all I am going to say. Much love to the Rent Posts.
I made a list of all your faults, it was quite detailed and lengthy too and when I read it through I missed you. Your like a classic Eagles song, you just cant help but sing along even though it sometimes gets annoying too. I just know I want to be wherever I can wake and see you there next to me. **High Fidelity** Love is what I do **The Wedding Singer** Xanadu - Best NEW Musical of the Season!
#9

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Personally I don't dislike Caplan, but I can't wait to see Hanke . . . I have seen clips of his other performances but have never seen him (if that makes sense!). Still no word on who will replace Tim though? Or did I miss it?
"I wrote a book: "How to Be Popular". Now I've put together a top ten list of how to help you: -Elphie, everyday... shower. I mean, who knows? Maybe some of that green is gonna come off! -Deodorant Elphie. No body likes a stinky witch! -I think we've covered the hair, we'll get to that. -Clean underclothes. That's all I'm gonna say. -Look at your posture. That's no way to be popular! -Bed made, room straightened. We've done that. -Colors blended. Oookay. -But the most important thing to have, to make yourself popular, is to keep your beautiful smile." ~Kristin Chenoweth in her last performance of the song "Popular"
#10

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I'm glad the show was amazing! I'm going to see it again today, so maybe I'll get some understudies because it's the matinee. I'm excited!
"For example, if I should paint my fingernails green - and it just so happens I do paint them green. Well, if anyone should ask me why, I say: 'I think it's pretty!'"
#11

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Thank you for the review. It's really interesting to read the different opinions re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen
"TO LOVE ANOTHER PERSON IS TO SEE THE FACE OF GOD"- LES MISERABLES--- "THERE'S A SPECIAL KIND OF PEOPLE KNOWN AS SHOW PEOPLE... WE'RE BORN EVERY NIGHT AT HALF HOUR CALL!"--- CURTAINS
#12

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Is Crystal the really, really skinny soloist?
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#14

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Matt needs to retire his scarf, because what I have seen/heard from him, it is like a robot! I think once a person is in the show for a year they need to re-audition and if they have gotten stale (like Matt) they need to be replaced.
"They're eating her and then they're going to eat me. OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!" -Troll 2
#15

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I have no problem with Matt save for his constant need to add sexual gestures and humor to the lyrics. Just a bit unnecessary in my opinion. Then again, I am sure some people like that.
#16

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I had the exact same cast on June 20th except Luther Creek was Mark and Frenchie was there. I loved it, as well.

If your show was only the 6th time Moeisha was there I wonder what the one I saw was for her. If she had only performed it once or twice when I saw it I am even more impressed.
#17

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I also love this cast. I haven't seen Tim or Nicole, but I do like everyone else. Crystal is certainly by no means skinny, but she is very talented. Her Joanne is one of my favorites.
#18

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Jyn326 I would have loved to have seen Luther Creek as Mark. How was he? I love his other work!
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
#19

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

I've seen Moeisha twice as Mimi and thought she was great!


I think she's done it more than 6 times though. I think around 10?

Updated On: 7/19/06 at 01:24 PM

#20

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Luther is a great Mark, and an even better Roger. He's one of the very few to have ever played both roles full-time.
#21

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

Nicole Lewis was Joanne? When did THAT happen? I'm glad she was great, though.
http://www.beintheheights.com/katnicole1 (Please click and help me win!) I chose, and my world was shaken- So what?
The choice may have been mistaken, The choosing was not...
"Every day has the potential to be the greatest day of your life." - Lin-Manuel Miranda
"And when Idina Menzel is singing, I'm always slightly worried that her teeth are going to jump out of her mouth and chase me." - Schmerg_the_Impaler
#23

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

just an update of today's matinee:
Antonique was out again and Karmine Alers was Mimi and she was amazing as always.
Frenchie was out and Moeisha took over she was pretty good, but her SoL solo didn't compare to Frenchie's at all.
Shaun Earl was out, too, so Owen Johnston II played Paul.

The show was great! Except I think Nicole needs to project more, because I definitely had trouble hearing some things she was singing.
"For example, if I should paint my fingernails green - and it just so happens I do paint them green. Well, if anyone should ask me why, I say: 'I think it's pretty!'"
#25

re: Rent Review, 7/18: Best Cast I've Ever Seen

If Crystal isn't really thin, then I'm thinking of someone else. The REALLY thin girl that covers for the soloist is just terrible.

I absolutely hate Matt Caplan in the show.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $101