I'd definitely suggest Godspell. I did the lottery last night and won, it wasn't too crazy... but I checked TKTS before heading to lottery just in case because I had my heart set on seeing it last night. Their lotto-loser policy is fill-in seats that are lotto-ed off after the lotto seats are gone. So they pull out 10-15 names more that are fill-ins all around the theater. The price and # of seats changes every night but last night there were 15 seats for $75 each.
When I went to TKTS, they had 50% off for last nights performance, bringing the tickets to about $60-65 each, said a representative. He told me if it's on the board, they usually have those tickets right up until show time. So I'd say definitely chance the lotto (for a great experience if you win!) and if not run over to TKTS which is only a few blocks down to get your tickets.
Another alternate, if you're interested, is Venus in Fur. When I lost Godspell yesterday afternoon, I ran over to Venus in fur and got a $27 rush ticket 12 minutes before curtain and enjoyed the show!
Updated On: 10/24/11 at 11:27 AM