Here are my thoughts....
I thought it was good, but not great.
Act 2 is MUCH better than act 1. It's a lot tighter, and the emotions get kicked up a notch in the second act. Act 1 feels very cartoony, where as in act 2, it feels much more "real," if that makes sense. However, as the original poster mentioned, the climax needs some re-working. It doesn't have the payoff that it should at this point. I'm sure they'll get it straightened out, though.
I was a little disappointed that my two favorite performers in the show- Aaron Tveit and Julia Murney are given so little to do. Murney has an awful song in Act 1 called "Orlando" (like the city) that needs to go. She does get a really good song in Act 2, however, and does a fantastic job with it. I also have to point out that she does not look at all like she could be Celia Keenan-Bolger's mother. That was kind of laughable.
Tveit does get one good song, but again, I was hoping for a little more. His acting, again, with not much to do, was very good.
The rest of the cast is all pretty good. The standout for me was Van Hughes as Patrick. I thought his acting was fantastic, and he brought a real vulnerability to the character.
Another pleasant surprise was Mary Faber as Hilary Faye. As someone mentioned, they've toned down the character some from the movie. Faber acts it very well, particularly in Act 2, where you get to see a bit of the character's humanity.
There are some nice moments in both the book and score, but neither one really blew away.
It was nice to see Jesse Vargas right back at work, conducting the band, after the Glory Days fiasco.
Overall, with some work, they'll have a nice little off-Broadway show. They shouldn't even be entertaining ideas of moving to Broadway, because the show is in the perfect venue right now.
The audience seemed to enjoy it a great deal, but there was no standing ovation.
Lights came up at 10:33, but the show started about 10 minutes after 8, so the run-time (at the moment) is about 2 hours, 20 minutes.
Updated On: 5/11/08 at 11:27 AM