Melanie73 said: "Lobby Hero is a great show, BUT it is really heavy/dark material. Not sure if that's something he might like, but that's something to consider.
Honestly, I would recommend Bronx Tale. A lot of friends of mine -- some of whom don't tend to like theatre/musical theatre very much -- enjoyed the show quite a lot. It's also pretty easy to get rush tickets! The only thing is that I haven't seen the show since the new lead stepped in, but I would imagine it's still a good show!
The only reason why I wouldn't recommend Band's Visit for him is that I'm not sure a non-theatre-lover would enjoy it. I enjoyed it immensely, but the feel of the show is so understated that I'm afraid someone who doesn't love musical theatre might be "bored."
If you can get tickets, I think he might be entertained by Hello Dolly. He might also like Once on This Island, I think! It's a brief show in an intimate venue, and the whole thing is such a spectacle that I think he might find it enjoyable!
Another suggestion I have is actually The Imbible, which is playing at New World Stages. I saw it with my roommate and a friend during the 20@20 promotion, and since we got in line kind of late, that was the only option left; I went in knowing very little about the show, but I left there SO pleasantly surprised! It's definitely not a traditional theatre experience by any means. It's so entertaining, and you actually learn some pretty interesting things about the history of alcohol production and consumption! It was so much fun, and if you guys drink alcohol, you get three drinks throughout the course of the show, included in the cost of the ticket! I don't even drink, so my three drinks were given to my roommate and our friend who came with us, but I still had a great time! DEFINITELY a show for a non-theatre-lover, and just a fun night out in general!"
Thanks. Another vote for Bronx. For lobby hero here are rush seats so maybe that’s a decent option. Since I’m really the theatre fan, all the ‘real’ money is spent on me:) Once in this island is another one I’m extremely excited about. He will like the fact that it is only 90 minutes, and maybe he can win the lottery. I’ll explore The Imbible. DH doesn’t drink at all so not sure on that. But he is interested in history, I will see. Thanks for the suggestions!