Jersey Boys - Haven't seen it, but I have a gut feeling it wouldn't be my cup of tea, as I haven't met a jukebox musical that I did like ... does Singin' in the Rain count, since the majority of songs had been written before. Oh dear.
Rent - I love it for what it once was. The current state the show is in is depressing.
Wicked - Not a fan. Boring music, awful lyrics, and a bad adaption of a good book. It does have lovely production values.
Phantom - Don't care for it at all. And the book was way better.
The Producers - I find it amusing. Not as good as the original movie, but the OBC was a pleasure to watch!
Spamalot - Hate it. I find it to be horribly unclever. And I'm a disgustingly huge Monty Python fan (own all the episodes, movies, loads of books). You'd figure it would be up my alley, but it rubbed me the wrong way entirely.
Cats - There's only a couple of songs that I like, but I will give it points for being daring and having some absolutely amazing choreography.
Miss Saigon - Has a few good tunes, but I'm pretty much neutral towards it.
Les Miz - An occasionally-moving dinosaur. My favorite of the Cameron Mackintosh shows.
A Chorus Line - Words can't express my love for it, though I think Chicago was a twee bit better.
Boy From Oz* - Never saw it.
Little Shop of Horrors* - Cute show.
Lestat* - I will say that I've never laughed harder at a show in my life, so my twenty-one dollars didn't go to a complete waste.
Avenue Q* - Not my favorite show, but I do enjoy it very much, and am very glad that it won the Tony over Wicked.
Rocky Horror Picture Show* - Awesome, campy fun.
Stop looking at my charisma.