ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "At a minimum, La La Land will probably do good business on the road and in amateur/regional licensing.
But it’s a strange assortment of people working on the Broadway-aimed version, and I think it’s too recent and too well liked to take a swing on the level of AN AMERICAN IN PARIS. Reminds me of the attempts to musicalize Umbrellas of Cherbourg, which didn’t work out."
I actually saw Umbrellas a thousand years ago in LA. I had never seen the movie, so I was new to it other than ‘I Will Wait For You’. Unlike La La Land, although a hit, the movie was still niche.
It was a very small show, in the huge Ahmanson theatre. I actually remember the swooniness of the production and I quite loved it. Ironically, it would probably have a better chance at success nowadays in a small theatre, e.g., the Booth or a 500 seat off-B theatre, because I think we are more accepting of small musicals that when it previewed in LA.