gym - if you are talking about me, I said it's one of the things wrong with the direction.
I happen to like the score and the performances. I think the direction is misguided but I don't dislike the show. And keep in mind, I am talking in depth, more or less, about the mic-concept situation. I'm very much exaggerating my complaints here and explaining in detail why I thought it seemed inconsistent.
When the concept works - it is fantastic. Maybe it is because he just understands how to execute the concept better than others or someone worked with him more, but Gallagher seems to consistently understand what he is trying to accomplish (or what Mayer is trying to accomplish) on that stage.
During his scene with Ilse you see a shy, reserved, disturbed boy. Then he sings (or rocks out, rather) DON'T DO SADNESS and you understand that inside that shy shell is a soul exploding.
For me, that's when the "concept" really clicked and I said, "Ah!"
TOTALLY F*CKED was another moment like that, if not a bit muddled. MAMA WHO BORE ME is almost there. DARK I KNOW WELL should have been one of those moments that really pulls you in to the characters' innermost thoughts.
Updated On: 5/18/07 at 03:00 PM