qolbinau said: "The fact that no passionate fan has even come to argue against my claim is depressing haha, as is they aren't releasing tickets till Jan as if they thought they had a Hamilton situation on their hands.
Maybe they just need to ramp up the marketing a bit and it's still early days.
Hi qolbinau: I was wondering if you'd care to speculate who you thought would make a more successful Norma than Close in a 16-week concert? And by successful, I mean a combination of artistic and commercial viability. I also share your skepticism of this being a financial success.
Most of the names that are bandied about on here when people talk about who they would like to see as Norma are people like Carolee Carmello or Donna Murphy i.e. great musical theatre actresses who aren't huge names outside of New York. I think they would be fabulous in the role, but I don't see them being financially viable. I think there would be interest in New York in seeing Patti finally do it, but I doubt she would sell as much as Close, but maybe I'm wrong.
Of course, someone from left field like Celine Dion or Madonna (ALW once mused that she might be good in a film version) would have absolutely no trouble selling out the Palace, or a younger A-list actress like Cate Blanchett, but realistically I don't see any of them doing it or being as good an actor AND singer as Close. I mean Celine would sing the heck out of it, but has she ever acted?
I dunno, when I play this 'what if' game I keep coming back to Close as the best option for this project. Of course, maybe a limited concert run of Sunset isn't a good idea at all, but if it is being done, I think the draw of getting a chance to see a legendary Tony winning performance again sounds like the best of the available options. I know I will most certainly be there! I got to see Jennifer Holliday do a local production of Dream Girls in 2007, twenty-five years later, and it was amazing. On paper a forty-something Effie White is more of a stretch than a seventy year old Norma.