Well, I had NEVER seen Sweeney in any format prior to seeing the revival . . . I was BLOWN AWAY! I sat sobbing in my seat at the end. I thought it was a very powerful telling of the story. My partner saw the original and HATED it, but was also blown away by the revival. One of the reasons he didn't like the original was that he felt the story got lost in the massiveness of the Uris, massiveness of the set, etc. I saw the DVD of the original (tour) and appreciated it, but wasn't as moved by the story.
I'm sure seeing the original live, I might have had a different reaction . . . I wish I would have had the opportunity, but it didn't happen.
". . . POP . . ."