Some good songs, but an awful show. I was really surprised at the number of people who thought it deserved the Tony for Best Musical. I do think the authors did make an attempt to try and address some issues prostitutes face (profiling, disease, physical abuse and drugs to name a few), but it was constantly undercut by odd moments of cuteness and frivolity (the aforementioned People Magazine and Hooker's Ball definitely come to mind). Hooker's Ball was just plain stupid, but People Magazine was downright creepy with its decidedly light touch. It reminded me of that offending lyric in I Love a Cop from Fiorello (likes me/strikes me line), but as if an entire song were fashioned around that sentiment without a hint of irony.
It's interesting to note that when it premiered, The Life was addressed by many as the pseudo-sequel to Sweet Charity. Given the criticisms that had been discussed regarding Sweet Charity's frivolous portrayal of taxi dancers (the idea that they are thinly veiled prostitutes is a whole other kettle of fish), I felt like The Life was something of an attempt at contrition, but it always seemed to retreat to the safety of Sweet Charity when things got "too real".
Like others, I thought My Body was a catchy tune and looked rather fun on the Tonys. But in the back of my mind, I kept thinking it was more of a pro-choice anthem because...prostitution is illegal in New York. If it was intended to be a political statement that prostitution should be legalized, it wasn't made clearly. I think I would feel the same way about a "This is my pot and I can sell it to anyone I want" song. I know that is a poor comparison, but the song never set quite well with me. Like the show itself, I got mixed signals.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
Updated On: 6/8/10 at 07:17 PM