Just finished the soundtrack, and I love this show. It's got really clever lyrics, the music has a classical, almost chamber feel, and the orchestrations are gorgeous.
I was really fascinated by the portrayal of Ichabod Crane as a man struggling with addiction. It's not a topic you see explored enough in musical theatre, and the show handled it in a tasteful manner.
The whole cast did a great job, but I especially liked Andy Mientus' portrayal as Ichabod. His 11 o'clock number was funny, exciting, and heartbreaking.
I can easily see this making it to off-Broadway in the future.