I have seen three as well...have not yet seen Milly. I really think all the girls I have seen have their own charm and special quality that's different from the other.
But like MATT1, I LOVED Sophia - she was my absolute favorite. She was funny, got the most laughs, was touching, and I could understand most everything she said. And her voice is lovely - she sings Naughty on the CD. She is also the youngest (over a year younger than the next youngest) and that's appealing to have such a little girl become this strong character. I am still not a huge fan of the show as a whole - but she made me love it the most.
I don't feel I can really say if I liked Bailey and Oona better because I saw one from the last row in the balcony and the other from the 8th row orchestra..totally different perspectives. I agree Bailey was the most even and capable at everything to me, though i couldn't always understand her. Oona played it the most dramatic and darkest in a lot of ways, is probably the weakest singer, but does very well in the acting area. She is the only one that I saw stumble over a few lines. I also found it hardest to hear her and I was close up (Sound department - ugh)
I would still like to see Milly if I can manage = and I would love to see Sophia again. Running out of time..
I know many Broadway shows are now recorded and saved at the Lincoln Center Library and Matilda was recorded in August I believe. It's noted that there were four actresses credited as the lead but it's Sophia's Matilda.(I just ran across that information). I suppose the Matilda people could have again put the names in a hat as they did on opening night to pick which Matilda would be filmed...or they picked Sophia. I have no idea. I am fairly sure the general public will not have access to any library show while it's still running.
Updated On: 11/30/13 at 10:00 PM