I loved it too. I was down in the front/right orchestra in Rosabud's section. Patti Cohenour sang her line in the opening number right next to me, and I completely fell head-over-heels in love with her from that moment to this day.
Buckley's singing WAS amazing in this show, and I remember how good George Rose, Cleo Laine and Howard McGillin all were. And the music was very unique. It managed to sound like a wonderful, "new" combination of pop, traditional Broadway and classic Music Hall, all at the same time.
I did see the show a year later, with Donna Murphy as Drood. Most of the principle cast was gone by then, except for George Rose (who was very tired in the role at that point). It was pretty forgettable.
But when I saw the full original cast in a preview performance, it really was an exciting piece of theatre.
EDIT: According to one original cast member, it was NOT a pleasant experience back stage however. She had a miserable time doing the show. Apparently, as soon as the Tony nominations came out, the atmosphere back stage changed completely... and not in a good way.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22