The thing to remember is that this show had a wonderful life on Broadway. You can't really say it outlived its usefulness b/c it had some great capacity numbers and made a lot of money, initially, for its investors.
I have to admit I use to be an AIDA junky (it was a Heather Headley thing), but then I turned to MILLIE after I saw it the first time. It is the end-all-be-all of "feel good" musicals and you just walk out of that theatre humming the music and feeling happy. I'll never forget Rob Ashford's innovative choreography, the great sets and costumes, or any of the individual performances I witnessed. It was a wonderful production that only improved the image of the original film.
What fun and what joy!
Visit Sutton Foster Online!