Three Penny Flop — Page 3

"To me, that means the story wasn't told"

Isn't that what they use previews for? I'm not saying you are wrong... your criticism is quite rational and clearly stated (which can not be said for most others)... or that it can be fixed... but... isn't fixing story clarity one of things previews or going out of town is for?

Also, the comments regarding previews from Michael Bennet are pretty disturbing to me. Yea, you pay full price... but they are previews... most always clearly labeled... and the PURPOSE of a preview is work out all the kinks and fine tune performances... so knocking a show during previews, while certainly your right, is kinda misguided and just sorta smells of bitchy-ness. If you don't want to give the show a chance... don't see it in previews.

Lastly...
"...as far as expectations, many people today seem to have an idea in their head of what a production SHOULD be and if it is not, they aren't willing to accept the director's vision or the playwright's work..."

I think this is a really spot on observation. It seems like a lot of people on this board have said "Oh well Threepenny Opera is supposed to be..." Why dislike the production because of what it doesn't do? Why not like it or dislike according to what appears on stage... not what you miss? I do understand that there is a certain integrity to a peice that should be maintained... but... it seems like a lot of the dislike of this revival... and many others... has a lot more to do with the reviewer's expectations and not the productions short commings.

kmc

---

the shills have died out this week. i wonder if they've given up.

---

oh i meant the 3 penny shills. there's some Drowsey ones out there as well. if you attack someone who doesn't share your "good" opinion of a show, you are a shill in my book. the 3 Penny ones were pretty nasty. all you can really do is put a show before the public, talk it up and let the chips fall. look at everyone who can't stand WICKED and it has done tremendously because it reaches people. ok, SOME people.

---

I'll be going to Three Penny soon.
Regarding the shills, I happen to know that there are assistants in at least 2 PR and production offices that come on the web to rep shows -- they have "talking points" etc and instructions to "discredit" people with opposing views.
A show really makes it's own fortune based on what's on the stage, not what is spread over the web. If something is boring or bad, the chorus is pretty loud and damning. A flak doesn't "love" the show, they're just trying to dominate opinion, which is not compelling. The voice of someone who passionately believes in a show, despite what might be said about it, carries a lot of energy and is persuasive and interesting.

---

it's the aggression i can't stand.

---

and that the shill, i mean poster, joined the first day of previews for that particular show.

---

Some of the negative views of shows are just as nasty and disgusting in their attacks on anyone who disagrees.

---

You said it, Penguin! (Although I can kind of understand the anger when you've just spent a hundred plus bucks on something you wound up hating.)

I hope I haven't been mistaken for a Three Penny Shill. It's true I did join right after I saw the show but only because I enjoyed the production and wanted to put in my two cents...or three cents, in this case. I've tried to be respectful while disagreeing with some of the detractors and have made comments on several other non-three penny threads.