just saw it tonight, pretty much agree with rent18.
i don't know dylan's work at all, but the show made me a fan, and appreciate the strong lyricist everyone says he is.
arden sings it beautifully, i think the boring notices being thrown out come from not really having a notable character of any sort. manuel was fine, i think her problem is she's stuck with awful contexts to sing the song, so it might be hard to connect the lyric with the story. sesma was fine as well, didn't really care for his character or why (it seems) we're suddenly supposed to care for him at the end.
orchestrations were really good, and the design elements are really great. fun to watch and listen to...one exception. the end features a moment that will probably make most people think of CATS, you'll have to see it to see what i mean.
if you didn't know the plot going in, you wouldn't know what the hell is going on, and that's a big problem. otherwise, it's just a bunch of people jumping around. (although i will say, i actually enjoyed the choreography here better than movin' out).
main problem i had is what i had with movin' out...hated that you could tell there were some really interesting things being sung, and you were just continually distracted by the dancing and the scenic elements - with this show, it's worse. i mean, there are people dancing on the trampolines over the pit and we're supposed to be following the lyrics?!
didn't go in with any expectactions and didn't leave with a memorable moment, really. some performances maybe we're strong, but too striking, but that's about it. otherwise just a whole lot of things to distract you from figuring out what was going on.
bob dylan and michael arden fans, i saw wait for the cast album.
"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008