GOOD
I have always been really pleased with the sight-lines in the Richard Rodgers. It's the theatre I've been to the most, and I've never had difficulty seeing anything. I also love the grandness and the beauty of it.
CITS was also fantastic, literally no bad seat. It's always a plus in my book when I can pay less and see more haha. I will take away points for the fact that there are basically two benches in the entire lobby, and you are not allowed to sit on the stairs, the floor, or anywhere else but those two benches (which fill up mighty fast) because it is apparently a fire hazard and for being far away, comparatively.
Schoenfeld also makes my list. Felt intimate, great sight-lines even though I had a terrible seat. I feel like I would be happy sitting basically anywhere in the theatre.
BAD
At the music box I felt like I was trying to maneuver around the heads of the people in front of me just to keep up with the plot. I haven't been back since Pippin, but that feeling stayed with me so here's a thumbs down. Real pretty though.
Gershwin always felt soulless to me, with no decor once you get into the theatre. Points for the awesome lobby and lots of space throughout, but loses points for being FAR compared to others.
Note: I haven't been to that many, as somehow I keep repeating theatres often. I do not sit in the mezz if I can help it and I do not tend to use the washroom at the theatre so I am not judging in that. I've not had significant issues with legroom in a broadway theatre (Now, the theatres back home...)