"What Makes Sammy Run
Barbour
Superman "
It shows how much theatre comes down to personal taste. Fifty years later, I still think 'What Makes Sammy Run' is one of the most boring musical's I have ever seen. It managed to have a good run because Steve Lawrence was very big at the time.
I assume you are referring to Bajour, which played the Shubert for a season.
Moving ahead, I would add:
Darling of the Day
Hallelujah! Baby!
The Happy Time (all three from the same season, interestingly)
Purlie
Coco (yes..saw it three times, once without Hepburn, and loved it all three times)
Over Here
Half a Sixpence
Drat! the Cat! (8 performances and I loved it and still remember a lot)