I wish there was not as much Spamalot-bashing as there has been. For one thing, why would someone go in expecting "great theatre"? It's Monty Python and Mike Nichols. There's your first clue.
I, for one, found the old material and the new material funny. Very funny the second time I saw it, which was with Simon Russell Beale as Arthur. I did not see Tim Curry the first time, but I highly doubt he was better than Beale was. Also, Hank Azaria, David Hyde Pierce, and especially Michael McGrath were all wonderful performers and delivered their lines fabulously. Unfortunately, Lauren Kennedy was not as funny as Sara Ramiriz was. She definetely deserved that Tony (Before anyone gives me death threats, I say that having seen Kelli O'Hara in Piazza and Celia Keenan-Bolger in Spelling Bee. In fact, I think Keenan-Bolger could have won it if Ramiriz did not).
Speaking of McGrath, he says one of my favorite lines in the whole show:
Patsy: Actually, sir, I'm Jewish.
Arthur: Well, why didn't you tell me, Patsy?
Patsy: Well, it's not something one says to a heavily armed Christian!
The way he sayed it made me laugh both times I saw it.
Basically, what I am trying to say is that I think people should lighten up about Spamalot, and vent their criticisms to show we know that pretty much everybody does not like, like Lestat or Hot Feet.
My avatar = A screencap from Avatar, arguably the greatest animated show of all