Snagged a rush ticket for last night's performance- what an altogether odd show. It's often entertaining and engaging, but somehow it doesn't fully come together. I think generally the problems lie in Act Two. The first act, I found, moves at a nice clip and is interesting- the second act drags considerably even though it isn't longer than the first.
Fundamentally, I don't think the creative team settled on what story they wanted to tell. Much of the show is spent valorizing Arden and Rubinstein as feminist trailblazers- women who dominated their field when that was so rare. It makes a good case for it too, but right at the end of the show they try to tack on a feminist critique of the cosmetics industry in general. I think that is worth exploring, but it needs to be introduced much earlier to really have weight. I think the writers were looking to have their feminist cake and eat it too, but ultimately it makes the show feel meandering rather than thought-provoking.
Of course, it's not surprise that Patti and Christine are wonderful. Frankel and Katie know how to utilize Christine's voice beautifully, and she sounds lovely. Still, I think the night belongs to Patti. She sounds glorious- it's hard to believe she's 61 when she sounds like that- and she gets the better lines. The show, too, seems to have a slight preference for Rubinstein as a character- she seems more serious and knowledgeable (and with the better product), while Arden is portrayed as sort of a society lady who figured out good marketing.
Thw rest of the elements are more or less fine. The score is pleasant but none of the numbers fully landed dramatically. Even Pink, which has been much praised, takes far too long to clearly make its point. The book is spare but more or less works, though it does get slack in Act Two. Dossett and Sills were fine but strangely interchangeable in both looks and performance- and yes, Dinosaurs needs to be cut. It underlines a point we already understand, and it lands like an absolute thud. The costumes (and the hats!) are unsurprisingly gorgeous.
I think this makes me sound like I hated the show, but I really didn't. It's a nice night in the theatre. I found the history interesting, as I was totally unfamiliar with both women, and it is really a treat to see Ebersole and LuPone onstage together. Still, I can't help but wish it were far more satisfying, either as a bio-musical or as a deep dive into the cosmetics industry and the effect it's had on American women and the perception of beauty.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.