Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced! — Page 4

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#76

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

"I disagree. Other than Alice Ripley, I thought Aaron Tveit was the best part about Next to Normal. You were drawn to his presence onstage, even in scenes where he was just lurking about, without a line of dialogue. In Hairspray, I thought he was great fun, and had excellent chemistry with Shannon Durig. I saw him in Saved, but he had nothing to do there. In Wicked, he acted and sang Fiyero better than anyone, and actually looked like he would be attending Shiz, not teaching there. He is also one of the very few Fiyeros who you don't think would rather run off with Boq than either of the witches."

I agree with everything in this post. I adore Aaron Tveit, I'd be doubled over in excitement if he was cast as Tony. However, I'm excited to see what Matt Cavenaugh does with the role.

#77

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

I disagree. Other than Alice Ripley, I thought Aaron Tveit was the best part about Next to Normal.

That would've been Brian d'Arcy James for me.

You were drawn to his presence onstage, even in scenes where he was just lurking about, without a line of dialogue.

I remember looking to see who was lurking, and then mine went right back to Ripley and BdJ.

In Hairspray, I thought he was great fun, and had excellent chemistry with Shannon Durig.

It looked like it pained him to smile. And Durig kept every Tracy/Link relationship afloat even if she had a weak link opposite her.

I saw him in Saved, but he had nothing to do there.

Valid. At least he looked fine shirtless.

In Wicked, he acted and sang Fiyero better than anyone.

I didn't think he did anything to enhance the already shoddy role.

So, let's just agree to disagree re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

Ultimately, I would've liked an unknown for Tony in this WSS revival.
#78

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

finally the announcements are in
i am curious about how they will approach this revival

Updated On: 10/30/08 at 03:04 AM

#79

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

When has Cavanaugh EVER been "incredible"? He's very pretty, very boring and has minimal range. Will Tony be speaking like Joe Kennedy as well?
#80

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

are they changing the choreography? at all/ or staying traditional to the original? mostly we hear about updating the dialogue and language fusion.

Updated On: 10/30/08 at 03:21 AM

#81

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

I think we can all agree that Matt's "wooden" acting won't be the only wood in the theatre.

Night after night.
-Benjamin
--http://www.benjaminadgate.com/
#83

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

hooray for Cavenaugh, Olivo, Holbrook, and ensemble Santos...love them all, personally and professionally!
Will: They don't give out awards for helping people be gay... unless you count the Tonys. "I guarantee that we'll have tough times. I guarantee that at some point one or both of us will want to get out. But I also guarantee that if I don't ask you to be mine, I'll regret it for the rest of my life..."
#84

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

LaMusicVa, I think the "girls in the gang" are referring to the jet girls and other shark girls. Such as Velma, Minnie, Graziella, margarita, teresita, etc....

I think you're right. I realized that after I posted...I think it was the wording of the press release that confused me, referring to 'the Jets,' and 'the Sharks,' collectively. I guess I'm used to the old cast list that divided everyone into groups.
#85

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

I think it was rumored that Matt Shingledecker was in final callbacks before they decided to skew older.

Also I'm pretty sure Natalie DID audition for Anita.
#86

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

Matt Shingledecker wasn't a rumor, that was true. He was in the final three being considered. I still think he would have been excellent, if they'd gone in a younger direction.

I think Cavenaugh is an interesting choice and I look forward to seeing him. However, possibly even more, I look forward to seeing his understudy, Matt Hydzik. Must be something about the name Matt and this role! re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!
#88

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

^^Unless something's changed in the past 24 hours, yes, I'm sure. :)
#90

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

I really enjoyed his Melchior. If anything he might've come across as too polished for Tony, but that's not like it's something that can't be worked on, I'd assume.
"This thread reads like a series of White House memos." — Mister Matt
#91

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

Olivo is fantastic in IN THE HEIGHTS, and she was particularly great in HAIR last year.
Matt Cavenaugh is a major bore, but I'll keep an open mind. But I am dissapointed about Curtis Holbrook, who I really disslike
#92

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

out of curiosity, other than cavanaugh, who else do people who are unexcited about the current cast think should be recast? who would you cast in their place?
#93

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

No one's talked about Josefina yet!

Also, I thought TooDarnHot KNEW FOR SURE that Aaron Tveit would be playing Tony. Oh, yeah, and he calls me a crazy liar.
#94

re: WEST SIDE STORY Cast Announced!

I wish Omar Lopez-Cepero could play Tony...i just think he's too unknown. He's only done a touring production of evita and was a finalist on NYMF's next broadway sensation.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $95