I disagree. Other than Alice Ripley, I thought Aaron Tveit was the best part about Next to Normal. That would've been Brian d'Arcy James for me.
You were drawn to his presence onstage, even in scenes where he was just lurking about, without a line of dialogue. I remember looking to see who was lurking, and then mine went right back to Ripley and BdJ.
In Hairspray, I thought he was great fun, and had excellent chemistry with Shannon Durig. It looked like it pained him to smile. And Durig kept every Tracy/Link relationship afloat even if she had a weak link opposite her.
I saw him in Saved, but he had nothing to do there. Valid. At least he looked fine shirtless.
In Wicked, he acted and sang Fiyero better than anyone. I didn't think he did anything to enhance the already shoddy role.
So, let's just agree to disagree
Ultimately, I would've liked an unknown for Tony in this WSS revival.