I listen to POTO over and over. Music of the Night is my favorite song of all-time. However, despite the weakness of the book and lyrics, Love Never Dies may have a slightly better score, because of the incredible waltzes. On the other hand, Phantom has the fake opera scores that could almost get me into liking real opera -- especially the comic scene where Carlotta croaks (literally). That music reminds me of Rossini, whom I love.
You alone can make my song take flight.