I'm not really sure its right just yet to start judging their performances based on last night. As an actor, I know its quite a tricky experience getting the show on its feet in front of an audience for the first time, because live theatre truly is a conversation... and hearing the other side of that conversation for the first time can throw you off a bit. Nerves can send you in all sorts of directions.
I took the night for what it was--a rehearsal. I wasn't expecting a crazy mind-blowing performances, and quite frankly, I was just happy to finally see Raul live on stage for the first time. I thought the whole cast was amazing, I can't pick a favorite out of the bunch. I was absolutely mesmerized by Ian McShane though...
I'm planning on seeing the show once it opens and the kinks have been worked out. The show has great potential.
Oh, and as for those "roped off" seats? My roommate and I snagged those at intermission... We spent the first act in the far right of the front row, staring at the back of the couch, so as far as we could tell, it was a radio play. :-P
Face life with a little guts and lots of *glitter*