I saw this the other night and am very mixed. The play itself is pretty good but the production is abysmal.
I found the acting to be pretty dreadful with the exception of Carolyn McCormick and Kristine Nielsen (whom I LOVE but I think her schtick is beginning to wear thin). I really enjoyed Noah Galvin in BURNT PART BOYS but here he is playing the comedy very broad and hokey. Honestly no one really made me think this play was set in 1945.
LarryD2 mentioned how the onstage drummer was unsuccessful and I'm going to second that plus a lot more. I actually HATED the drummer. I go to plays all the time and hardly any of them rely on the use of sound effects and a constant underscoring during every scene. Even though there isn't a car there, I'm pretty sure I understand that they're getting in one based on the actions and props.
That leads me to the biggest fault of all...the scenic design. The stage is pretty much bare except for a white wall and floor with a bench. This is because all of the scenic design is done through everyone's favorite: PROJECTIONS. These aren't your usual projections though, it's a litany of typed words/letters/lines from the script. It's all very distracting because I spent time trying to decipher what was written on the wall during the show. Another misstep was having stage directions projected onto the wall. I don't know if this is something written in the play itself but it's all wrong. If Ted is going to walk on set singing a song then just have him do it, don't tell me it's going to happen and then have me watch it.
All in all, I'd say you wouldn't miss much if you skipped this and just read the play yourself.
"Pardon my prior Mcfee slip. I know how to spell her name. I just don't know how to type it." -Talulah