What do you think of Shoshana? — Page 5

as of right now, she still hasnt changed the notes.. its not just the note changing, its aboout being comfortable being that high in your chest voice.. i hate sitting in a theatre wondering if they will hit the notes which Idina made me think about, I dont have that problem with Shoshana.. its really a matter of opinion

You know what? I do NOT like Shoshana Bean as Elphaba. As much as I thought that her voice was great and her mastery of the role decent, she is simply not that hot. My sister and I both read the book, and it is clear that Elphaba is supposed to be hot, just green. Idina Menzel was hot. Shoshana is not.

Come on, now, even after Glinda's transformation she doesn't look that good. When is she going to be replaced? I want someone hot to join the cast. She doesn't deserve to make out with David Ayers.

Wow, there certainly are a wide variety of opinions here ...

I've never seen the show, but have heard recordings of Bean, Thompson, Hilty, Bundy, and Espinosa. I'm really kind of confused at comments like Bobby's saying that Bean was off key. True, I like Idina's voice better than Shoshana's in the role, but I rather perplexed at the folks who seem to find her that horrible. I like Bean's voice and she seems to give a decent performance, vocally, I just wasn't completely blown away. I like her Wizard and I well enough, but her voice just doesn't seem to work out with Defying Gravity. I absolutely loved her No Good Deed however; I thought she sang with alot more emotion than Idina. Can't really comment on her acting skills, but from the recordings it didn't seem horrible.

As for Eden Espinosa, in my opinion she just can't belt. Her Wizard and I was halfway decent, but her Defying Gravity killed me, and her No Good Deed was really shaky. She sounds lovely in the gentle songs though, like For Good and As Long as You're Mine. And the Glinda (possibly Laura Bell Bundy?) I heard her paired with in Defying Gravity was horrible humor-wise. Ill-timed lines and a bit pathetic. Can't recall how she was vocally.

Don't get me started on Jennifer Laura Thompson ... I keel over laughing at all her lines in the opening sequence, Popular, and Defying Gravity. What incredibly timed humor, emotional believable acting, and a drop-dead gorgeous voice. I wish her contract was extended for about 5 more years. I liked her better than Chenoweth.

LOL All this and I've never seen the show.

---

i've never seen her, i was lucky to catch Idina!

---

I'll find out June 14th just how good or bad Ms. Bean is. Just purchsed my tickets this afternoon. I'm actually really looking forward to seeing Megan Hilty as Glinda.

As much as I'm anxiously awaiting Shoshana's performance, she's going to have to kick some serious ass to beat Idina in my mind.

I'm seeing Shoshana in a few weeks...so I'll know then, but from clips I've heard she sounds like she has the singing part of the role down...

As for the comment about Elphaba being "hot" in the book, I'm not sure where you got that from. She was supposed to be skinny, tall, angular, and not particularly attractive. If I remember correctly, she had a long nose and rather pointy features. The only thing that they mentioned as pretty was her hair.

---

I agree Bso...she was definitely on top of her game that last week...I saw her on the 4th and she blew me away.

And I agree with the hotness...Idina = magnet...Kimmy = small metal object.

---

She sucks. She is no Britany.

---

How odd...I violently disagree( An exaggeration-I am a peaceful person ) with some of the posts.
1) I Definitely think Eden is the hottest Elphaba. Idina is somewhat hot, Stephanie Block is beautiful, and Shoshana is attractive.
This is for Benzy92-I am going to try, if somewhat inarticulately, to explain why I like Shoshana's singing:
I have seen both Shoshana and Idina and I definitely, 100 % prefer Shoshana's singing. Her voice is amazing. I love that I don't hear straining every time she opens her mouth-and, like someone else said, I like not having to worry about whether or not she will hit the notes. I feel like she has more command/control over her voice and I appreciate that a pretty sound comes out. When Idina sings the big numbers in "Wicked" her voice never sounds..pleasing. I feel like she beats me over the head with the note( whether she hits it or not).

RE: Acting. I never felt like Idina did the best job acting in "Wicked" but I do think she is a better actor than Shoshana. IMO: the best actor I have seen amongst the 4 leads is JLT. She has impeccable comedic timing, in addition to a dramatic understanding which inevitably lends itself to the most fully realized character on the stage.

---

Updated On: 3/19/05 at 12:54 AM

Ive heard recordings of shoshana, idina and eden. Eden has the most vocal power in my opinion, but is sometimes too sharp and too over the top. Idina originated it and made it her own. shoshana sounds wonderful and has more of a singing voice rather than a screaming. dont get me wrong, idina can give me serious "good" chills, but so can shoshana.

Eden hotter than Idina!?!?!?!

Yeah, OK....

(note the sarcasm in my words)

ugh you all make me SICK

Updated On: 3/23/05 at 06:07 PM