#51
Posted: 10/23/04 at 6:51pm
"Bal, you are my new favorite person."
Your avatar is my new favourite person. "It's a pretty rock, with speckles! Vendetta GAVE it to me!" :) Muchas Gracias.
"Fiyero in Wicked. They just threw out his back story and made him just a love interest."
But isn't a love interest a nice plot device? I'm not a big Wicked fan, you can probably tell, but I believe that how deep the friendship of Elphaba and Glinda is really emphasized by Glinda's disregarding losing her boyfriend to the green girl. It shows how much the character changes from a greedy, self-absorbed 'popular' girl to a mature woman who understands both friendship and priorities. Besides that, just because Fiyero has been changed to a un-diamonded white boy who dates Glinda doesn't mean he's not a valuable character to the show. When comparing a book and musical that are so drastically different, I usually find it best to look at the book and musical (or movie, as the case may be) as two seperate entities, and enjoy them both on seperate levels. Or, in Wicked's case, try my best to enjoy them.
"LostWallflower, funny you should mention the kid in Assassins. Yeah, it just threw me a bit when I saw it and now when I listen to it to hear him singing "Something Just Broke". The adults made sense of course but it just seems to me that a kid that age would not be that affected. Just my thoughts!"
My mother has spoken about the Kennedy assassination a couple of times to me. While we're both Canadian, and always have been, it affected her very deeply and she was only fifteen. It wasn't the loss of the US President so much as the reactions of the adults around her, the coverage, and the power of this one small man (LEe Harvey Oswald) to bring a nation, quite literally, to a standstill. I haven't heard the song in awhile, but I think it would be interesting to delve deeper into the kid's emotions. I'm sure a child would be parroting a lot of what he'd be hearing adults saying about the president's murder.
And some children are more perceptive than you might think.
Anyways, I hope I haven't offended you. I don't want to seem like I'm attacking you, I'm just in a typing sort of mood and am up for a good debate. No hard feelings?
Your avatar is my new favourite person. "It's a pretty rock, with speckles! Vendetta GAVE it to me!" :) Muchas Gracias.
"Fiyero in Wicked. They just threw out his back story and made him just a love interest."
But isn't a love interest a nice plot device? I'm not a big Wicked fan, you can probably tell, but I believe that how deep the friendship of Elphaba and Glinda is really emphasized by Glinda's disregarding losing her boyfriend to the green girl. It shows how much the character changes from a greedy, self-absorbed 'popular' girl to a mature woman who understands both friendship and priorities. Besides that, just because Fiyero has been changed to a un-diamonded white boy who dates Glinda doesn't mean he's not a valuable character to the show. When comparing a book and musical that are so drastically different, I usually find it best to look at the book and musical (or movie, as the case may be) as two seperate entities, and enjoy them both on seperate levels. Or, in Wicked's case, try my best to enjoy them.
"LostWallflower, funny you should mention the kid in Assassins. Yeah, it just threw me a bit when I saw it and now when I listen to it to hear him singing "Something Just Broke". The adults made sense of course but it just seems to me that a kid that age would not be that affected. Just my thoughts!"
My mother has spoken about the Kennedy assassination a couple of times to me. While we're both Canadian, and always have been, it affected her very deeply and she was only fifteen. It wasn't the loss of the US President so much as the reactions of the adults around her, the coverage, and the power of this one small man (LEe Harvey Oswald) to bring a nation, quite literally, to a standstill. I haven't heard the song in awhile, but I think it would be interesting to delve deeper into the kid's emotions. I'm sure a child would be parroting a lot of what he'd be hearing adults saying about the president's murder.
And some children are more perceptive than you might think.
Anyways, I hope I haven't offended you. I don't want to seem like I'm attacking you, I'm just in a typing sort of mood and am up for a good debate. No hard feelings?
"Well, obviously Company is about the Kennedy family. Bobby is played by Raul, and JFK is played by Harvey Fierstein."
-vfd88
Updated On: 10/23/04 at 06:51 PM