Hey Best12, thanks for taking the time to answer my question.
I really can't give a concrete reason as to why I dislike it so much. It's sort of like if you don't like a certain food. I just don't like broccoli. I don't know why. It's the taste. I guess the show leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
With certain things, ie, the movie Crash, I can tell you 100 very intelligent reasons why I hated it. I definitely respect and understand that A Chorus Line was revolutionary at its time. And I would never think we should discard it because it is dated. I just think certain shows... hold up differently and thus should be treated differently.
I can start I guess with the music. I really dislike it. For me, a musical is all about the music. If the music is not good, the show really has no legs. I mean, why not be a play instead? And there is nothing worse than sitting through bad music. The reason musicals are musicals is because they attempt to do something with music that you can only do on the stage and that is needed for the story. I look at my favorite shows, Sweeney Todd, Cabaret, Evita, Ragtime, and Caroline or Change, and I say "yes, those shows used music to its fullest and gave me something incredible." I can't tell you why I dislike the music from A Chorus Line other than, as I said, a lot of it sounds like commercial jingles, is bland, and lacks that feeling, in my opinion.
I love the theatre, but I, myself, have no interest in acting or being an actor. Maybe deep down I could care less about A Chorus Line's message. I mean, to me, it always just came off as whining. We all have jobs, but we deserve a musical about them? I work in publishing... where is my musical documenting my travails with comma faults? I have always been uncomfortable around those "drama personalities" who I perceive to exaggerate everything and always be the center attention. I went to high school with a lot of people like that, and my thoughts are... "yawn."
Lastly, I am gay and for my own psychological reasons I did not like the gay aspect of the show one bit. I know it is dated, but again, for my own reasons, I found it insultingly trivial. But, let's not psychoanalyze that. Let's just say it was no Brokeback Mountain. :)
Updated On: 9/2/06 at 10:51 PM