Bravo, Kent. Nicely done, and well put!
I will only add this about the music...
Perhaps it sounds corny or dated, or like "commercial jingles" because it was imitated quite a bit, back in its day. I'm not implying that a brand new sound of pop music was created for this show, because it wasn't. But Hamlisch (and his music team of arrangers & orchestrators) did have their pulse on theatricalizing the current pop music trends of the day.
I remember thinking that when I first heard the score to the movie Rocky (which was released the following year after ACL opened), that "Gonna Fly Now," particularly toward the end of the song and theme, sounded a hell of a lot like Cassie's final dance break (when her tempo speeds up again), in ACL. Imitation is the highest form of flattery. Of course, the song "ONE" isn't meant to sound current, and WAS meant to be derivative. It's supposed to be instantly recognized by all as the big "salute-the-star" number, specifically like Jerry Herman's title songs for "Hello, Dolly!" and "Mame." That was most definitely intentional on Hamlisch and Kleban's part. SHE'S the one... not them. Not the chorus members. It's all about being unique and individual... but it's all for HER, the big star who's not there in the number yet.
Where Hamlish and the original ACL music team really succeed in being fresh is in their structure. It's VERY unusual for a Broadway score to be structured the way ACL is. You have numbers within numbers ("Nothing" is INSIDE of "Hello, Twelve"), and particularly the Hello, Twelve montage, in all its various sections, is incredible in the way it weaves in and out of spoken dialogue, song fragments, a full song, monologues and dance sections. That was pretty unique for its day. Other songs too, like Music and the Mirror, going back and forth between dialogue and song fragments, before launching into the main portion of the song, and ultimately the extended dance. And the opening, "God I Hope I Get It," same thing. A wonderful "organic" structure, spinning free-form in a stream-of-conscious way, and not relying on expected musical formats.
If you know the music only from the cast recording, then you are in for a big surprise when you first see it live, and realize how fragmented, progressive, and yet ultimately flowing the score is.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 9/4/06 at 06:23 PM