I have to add my two cents here..
I went to NYC for the first time in February 2004. I was able to see four shows-- Phantom of the Opera, Chicago, Producers (with Matthew B. and Nathan L.) and Avenue Q. Although The Producers was funny, Chicago was good, Phantom of the Opera not all I expected, Avenue Q turned me on to Broadway... As a matter of fact, I saw it again when I came back to the city two weeks ago. I LOVE THE SHOW! I understand that its merits have been debated, but I listen to the OBCR, or at least part of it, on a daily basis... it's that catchy... However, I've also added the bare sampler CD to my rotation too, because I really like it (but that's another thread... which happens to be quite lengthy). As I saw mentioned in another thread, it has been asserted that Broadway needs to change with the times if it is going to survive. I think that Avenue Q is a new, fresh show that, while it may not necessarily be in a revival 20 years from now, can (and in my opinion, should..) be appreciated for being simple, but very entertaining. I agree with those who say that the recording makes more sense after you see the show, but I feel it stands very well on its own. I'll stop rambling, but, I think you get the picture--- I LOVE IT!
Peter, you tend to dramatize. There's a reason for that mother. Open your eyes. -- Bare
