Zoneface, that's what I was thinking. Tevye doesn't have to be attractive, nor does Edna in Hairspray or Leigh Bowery in Taboo, these are all Leads. Basically, you want to look at becoming a character actor. Not that this is anything to frown upon. I think I'm a character actor, but I'm not quite sure, because I always get stuck doing the sappy romantic lead, which I hate. I'm somewhere in between, because I seem to impress at first the romantic lead, but really I think I make a better character actor... whatever :P
I hold a degree in Musical Theatre from Montclair State University. It is useless. Now I'm funny for money. Oh, and I sing.