'so exactly what is the difference between idina's and shoshana's take on elphie?'
I don't think their portrayal is that different. I thought Idina's emotions were more 'visible' than Shoshana's (Idina got angrier, sadder etc) whereas Shoshana doesn't quite go through these emotions in my opinion.
I'm not a big fan of Shoshana, having seen her four times as Elphaba now. I think someone on the ATC board summed it up for me... she's just lacking the 'wow factor'. Her BIG notes are a lot softer and she tends to overact even more than Idina in the big numbers (You can only see arms in her No Good Deed, for expample).
Anyway, people love her and it's just my preference. I'd day she's a good Elphaba but certainly doesn't bring the house down for me. But then again, as so many people said 'the role is the star', so no matter who plays the role people will love her
QM
'He really wasn't good as Fieyro. Is it just me or does he sort of come across as a pimp? Just...the hand motions I've seen him do and the attitude..not that Taye is a pimp.' - SallyBrown on Taye Diggs as Fiyero
Updated On: 1/12/05 at 04:23 PM